Carlisle ATV Black Rock

The Carlisle ATV Black Rock is a solid choice for off-road enthusiasts who prioritize traction on varied terrain. Its handling score of 6.5 aligns with the all-terrain category average, ensuring dependable control both on and off the road. However, the tire's wet grip score of 4 falls short of the category average of 5.2, which could be a concern for drivers who often encounter wet conditions. In terms of comfort, the Black Rock matches the category average with a score of 6, offering a balanced ride typical of all-terrain tires. However, it lacks a treadwear warranty, unlike competitors such as the Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015, which may offer more peace of mind regarding longevity. Noise levels are average, with a score of 5, which might be noticeable during long highway drives compared to quieter alternatives like the Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season. For those who frequently drive in wet conditions, the Black Rock's lower wet grip performance could be a dealbreaker. In such cases, considering options with better wet traction, like the Toyo Open Country A/T III, might be wise. However, if off-road capability is your primary concern, the Black Rock remains a viable option.

Spec-based analysis — see our methodology.