Tire Scouter

How we score tires

Tire Scouter does two things. It finds the tires that fit your exact trim, and it gives each one an estimated spec score so you can compare them at a glance. This page explains both, and what the score can't tell you.

By Tirescouter Editorial · Updated October 2026

Manufacturer specsTreadwear, traction, temperature, warranty and speed rating.
5
Road testsThe score is an estimate, not a test result.
0
Owner reviewsNo review data goes into it.
0

Fitment comes first

You pick a year, make, model and trim. We look up that trim's factory front and rear tire sizes and list every tire in our catalog made in those sizes. We only say a tire fits once the trim and its size are known.

Some trims offer more than one wheel size, so they list more than one tire size. Before you buy, check the size printed on your current tires' sidewall or the sticker inside the driver's door.

The spec score

The spec score is an estimate built from five manufacturer specs, and nothing else. Each one becomes a rating out of 10. Here's an example grade for each, and the rating it earns:

  • 820

    Earns 8.4 of 10

    UTQG treadwear

    The federal wear grade the manufacturer assigns, relative to a reference tire. Higher should last longer, though grades aren’t strictly comparable across brands.

    A grade of 200 earns 3 of 10 points, rising evenly to 10 at 1,000.

    Weight Full

  • AA

    Earns 10 of 10

    UTQG traction

    The federal grade for straight-line braking on wet pavement: AA, A, B or C.

    AA earns 10 points, A 7.5, B 5 and C 2.5.

    Weight Full

  • A

    Earns 10 of 10

    UTQG temperature

    The federal grade for resisting heat build-up at speed: A, B or C.

    A earns 10 points, B 6.5 and C 3. Most tires grade A or B, so it rarely separates them.

    Weight Half

  • 70k

    Earns 7.4 of 10

    Mileage warranty

    The treadwear warranty the manufacturer offers, in miles.

    20,000 miles earns 3 of 10 points, rising evenly to 10 at 100,000 miles.

    Weight Full

  • V

    Earns 8.5 of 10

    Speed rating

    The top sustained speed the tire is rated for, as a letter.

    Y, W or Z earns 10 points, V 8.5, H 7.5, S or T 6. Lower ratings aren’t counted.

    Weight Half

We average the ratings a tire has, counting temperature and speed rating at half weight, and multiply by 10, so the five example grades above make a spec score of 88. Scores are kept between 30 and 98. A tire needs at least two of the five specs to get a score. With fewer, its label says “No data” rather than guessing.

Tier words on the label

Excellent
85 and up
Strong
72 to 84
Good
60 to 71
Fair
Below 60

Reading the scale

A score means most next to other scores, so each label places it on a scale. On your results, the scale runs from the lowest to the highest spec score among the tires that fit your trim. On a tire's own page, it runs across every tire in the same category.

What the score leaves out

  • No road tests. We don't test tires, and the score doesn't measure braking distance, handling, noise or comfort.
  • No review data. Owner reviews, star ratings and review counts play no part, and we don't show them.
  • No price. Cost doesn't raise or lower a score.
  • Severe-snow (3PMSF) and noise-reduction features appear on tire labels but don't change the score.
  • Winter tires are exempt from UTQG grading, so they often have fewer inputs and a lower or missing score. That says nothing about their grip in snow.
  • Performance tires trade treadwear for grip by design, so they tend to score below touring tires. Compare scores within the kind of tire you want.

Written analysis

Many tire models have written analysis: a summary, pros and cons, a “best for” note and any dealbreaker. Tirescouter Editorial writes it with AI assistance from each tire's specs, and checks it for review or test claims. The writing process also produced rough 0–10 ratings for traits such as wet grip and comfort, guessed from a tire's category. Those aren't manufacturer specs, so we don't show them or any sentence that quotes them. Tires without analysis show their specs only.

Prices and stores

We don't show dollar prices. Retailer price data is used only to sort by price and to set a relative price tier ($, $$ or $$$).

Some retailer links earn us a commission: Amazon Associates, the eBay Partner Network and Mavis Tire (through CJ). Stores we have an affiliate program with are listed first in store lists. Commissions never change a spec score or which tires we list, and brands can't pay for placement. See our affiliate disclosure.

Limitations

No tire database is perfect. Our specs and fitment come from a data snapshot we refresh periodically, so a manufacturer's latest changes can take time to appear. Some tires are missing specs, and some have no analysis yet. Use Tire Scouter to narrow the field quickly, then confirm the size for your trim and think about your climate and driving before you buy.

Put it to work

Start with your vehicle, compare a few strong options, then read up on the tradeoffs.