Carlisle ATV AT489

The Carlisle ATV AT489 is tailored for drivers who prioritize off-road capability over on-road finesse. Its all-terrain design ensures solid traction on mixed surfaces, making it a good choice for those who venture off the beaten path. However, its wet grip score of 4 falls short of the category average of 5.2, which could be a liability in wet weather. In terms of handling and comfort, the ATV AT489 performs adequately, matching the category averages. This balance makes it a reasonable option for drivers who need a tire that can handle both off-road adventures and daily driving. However, the lack of a treadwear warranty is a downside, especially when compared to competitors like the Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015, which offers a mileage guarantee. For those comparing options, the Toyo Open Country A/T III and Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season may offer better on-road performance, particularly in wet conditions. The ATV AT489's limited dry grip and absence of a treadwear warranty might deter those who prioritize long-term value and on-road reliability. If wet weather performance is a critical factor for you, consider alternatives with better wet grip ratings. Otherwise, the ATV AT489 is a capable choice for off-road enthusiasts who can overlook its on-road limitations.

Spec-based analysis — see our methodology.