Carlisle ATV All Trail II

The Carlisle ATV All Trail II is a solid choice for off-road enthusiasts who prioritize traction on varied terrains. Its handling and comfort scores align with category averages, making it a balanced option for mixed-use scenarios. However, its wet grip score of 4 is notably below the category average of 5.2, which could be a concern for those encountering frequent rain or wet conditions. In the all-terrain category, off-road traction is paramount, and this tire delivers in that regard. However, the absence of a treadwear warranty and UTQG ratings leaves some uncertainty about its longevity and performance consistency compared to competitors. The lack of these metrics is a disadvantage when considering long-term cost of ownership and reliability. When compared to competitors like the Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015, which offers a 60,000-mile warranty, the ATV All Trail II might not be the best choice for those looking for guaranteed longevity. The Pirelli Scorpion Zero All Season and Toyo Open Country A/T III also offer more comprehensive specifications, making them worth considering for those who need a more robust all-around performer. Overall, if wet grip and warranty coverage are top priorities, consider looking at the Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015 or similar alternatives for better assurance in those areas.

Spec-based analysis — see our methodology.