Toyo A24

The Toyo A24 is a decent choice for drivers looking for a touring all-season tire with good wet grip and a comfortable ride. Its wet grip score of 7.5 surpasses the category average, making it a solid performer in rainy conditions. Comfort and noise are both rated at 8, which matches the category benchmarks, ensuring a smooth and quiet driving experience. However, the tire's treadwear rating of 300 is a significant drawback, falling well below the category average of 596. This suggests a shorter lifespan, and the absence of a treadwear warranty only adds to the uncertainty about how long these tires will last. The R speed rating also limits its performance at higher speeds compared to some competitors. When compared to rivals like the BFGoodrich Advantage Control, which offers a 75,000-mile warranty, the A24 falls short in terms of long-term value. The Continental ProContact TX and ContiProContact also offer more robust treadwear ratings. Therefore, while the A24 might appeal to budget-conscious buyers initially, those who drive long distances or at higher speeds might find better value elsewhere. Avoid the Toyo A24 if you need a long-lasting tire with a solid warranty. Consider options like the BFGoodrich Advantage Control for better tread life and warranty coverage.

Spec-based analysis — see our methodology.